Teleplay by Jennifer Levin & Josh Reims
Story by Julie Blumberg & Joy Gregory
Directed by Stephen Gyllenhaal

Guest starring

Sarah-Jane Potts as Molly
Donald Faison as Tracy
Eddie Cahill as James
Juanita Jennings
Steve Eastin
Tony Guma
David Smigelski
Robert Patrick Benedict as Richard
Eve Gordon as Barbara Hunter

Co-starring

Frank Crim as dad
Wesley Singerman as Oscar

Featured music

"Amsterdam" by Sebastian Robertson & Raney Shockne (Felicity's mom arrives)
"Swingle Bells" by Brad Hatfield Trio (Noel & Felicity at Dean & Deluca)
"Bubble Bath" by Javier Mosley (Tracy tells Elena about Africa)
"Silent Night" by The Accidentals (James calls Molly and talks to her)
"O Tannenbaum" by Vince Guaraldi (Meghan tells Sean the tree idea was hers)
"O Little Town of Bethlehem" by Mark Stephen Ross (Felicity, her mom, Noel, and Ben at dinner)
"O Christmas Tree" by Mark Stephen Ross (Felicity, her mom, Noel, and Ben at dinner)
"We Three Kings" by Mark Stephen Ross (Felicity, her mom, Noel, and Ben at dinner)
"My Christmas Present is You" by Black Toast Music (Meghan gets her whip)
"We Three Kings" by Danny Pelfrey (Ben and Barbara at Dean & Deluca)
"Jingle Bells" by New York Latin All-Stars (Sean gives away the tree)
"Sometimes" by Spearhead (first party song)
"Love'll Set Me Free" by Spearhead (Ben arrives at the party)
"Absurd" by Fluke (ending song)